randombio.com | science commentary
Thursday, December 08, 2016
Do flickering lights cure Alzheimer's disease?Here's a summary of what Iaccarino et al. really found in that craaaa-zy Nature paper.
he news media are reporting that researchers have cured Alzheimer's in mice by shining a flickering light on them. Well, of course it's not that simple. Here's what is really going on in that Nature paper by Iaccarino et al.
What theory were they testing?
The idea was that disrupted gamma oscillations have something to do with Alzheimer's. It would make sense, because electrical oscillations in the brain depend on intact neurons and neuronal connections, which are damaged in Alzheimer's disease.
What are gamma oscillations?
Gamma oscillations (or gamma waves) are the highest frequency of electrical oscillations (around 40 Hz) in the brain. Some neurologists think they may be related to attentive focus.
Are these ordinary mice?
No, mice can't get Alzheimer's disease. The researchers used genetically mutated mice called 5XFAD mice. As the name suggests, they have five different mutations. This is a very unrealistic model since no patient has more than one mutation, but these mice make huge amounts of Abeta and get sick very quickly. This makes it easier to find ways to protect against Abeta, which is a toxic protein that scientists believe causes many of the symptoms of Alzheimer's.
How could a light cure Alzheimer's?
The light was used to induce gamma oscillations. First the researchers implanted fiber optic cables in the hippocampus, which is the region most strongly affected by Alzheimer's. Then they mutated the mice some more to make their neurons respond to light. They did this by injecting a special virus called AAV that contained a protein called channelrhodopsin2 fused to eYFP (yellow fluorescent protein).
AAV is a benign, non-harmful virus that does not hurt the mice. When the virus replicated it filled the brain cells with light-sensitive proteins. The researchers sent a blue light from a laser through the fiber optic cables to activate these light-sensitive proteins, which caused the neurons to fire. This is called optogenetic stimulation. The laser was pulsed to stimulate the neurons at 40 Hz. They found a 53% decrease in Abeta (a.k.a. beta-amyloid or Aβ).
Then they repeated the experiment with ordinary mutant mice and an ordinary LED light source, set to flicker at 40 Hz, in their cage. This also worked, but only in the visual cortex, which is not much affected by AD.
Finally they showed that even in normal mice, which have almost no Abeta at all, with no virus and no fiber optic cable, and which cannot get Alzheimer's disease, a 40 Hz flickering LED light reduced the amount of Abeta in the visual cortex by the same amount as in the AD mice.
What does this mean?
It means that increasing the synchronized oscillations in the brain can reduce the amount of Abeta. The microglia had gotten bigger and started engulfing the Abeta. This means they shifted toward a phagocytic state.
What did it do to plaques?
It reduced plaques and soluble Abeta by the same amount. Scientists have known for over two decades that plaques are harmless. But some researchers use plaques as a proxy for the amount of Abeta, because they are easier to detect.
Why is the result important?
It means that neuronal activity may play a role in converting microglia to a phagocytic state, which is one way the brain clears away Abeta.
We should keep in mind that hundreds of other things have also gotten rid of Abeta in transgenic mice. They are not a particularly good model for Alzheimer's because what works in these mice has very often not worked in people. There are also unresolved questions in the paper that scientists will need to understand, such as why the Abeta was reduced by half regardless of the initial amount of it. We should also keep in mind that the idea that Abeta causes Alzheimer's is still only a theory. We have no idea why Abeta is there, but we can be sure it's there for a reason.
What will it mean for patients?
Nobody is going to use light to treat Alzheimer's. Please don't run out and buy a flickering light bulb. It will just give you a headache. But there are many ways researchers could use the results to help patients.
If all of the above pan out, they'll recommend everybody keeping their mind active. It might turn out that not using your brain makes you more susceptible to Alzheimer's. If so, then reading web pages about Alzheimer's disease could be the best way to prevent it.
Last edited dec 09 2016, 5:57 am
Solanezumab drug trial failure: curtains for the beta-amyloid theory?
The solanezumab clinical trial failure hasn't eliminated beta amyloid as a potential cause of Alzheimer's disease.
Little known facts about Parkinson's disease
An exciting new treatment involves electrical stimulation instead of L-DOPA.
Subcortical vascular dementia
Vascular dementia is the loss of mental faculties caused by a problem in the blood vessels in the brain.
Nietzsche and the girl from treponema
Recent evidence proves that Nietzsche's dementia was not caused by syphilis.
Let me tell you about my trouble with girls in the lab
Male and female brains are wired differently for pain.